BIG-bench

On this page 8

BIG-bench, short for the Beyond the Imitation Game Benchmark, is a large collaborative benchmark of more than 200 tasks designed to measure the capabilities and limitations of large language models. In model evaluation, it is used to study how performance changes with model scale and to find tasks that current models still cannot solve.

The benchmark was released in 2022 by a community of more than 450 contributors from over 130 institutions. Its tasks range from arithmetic and logical deduction to linguistics, social reasoning and humor, which makes BIG-bench a broad capability survey rather than a single-skill test such as GSM8K or HumanEval.

How BIG-bench is structured

BIG-bench organizes its content as a collection of independent tasks, each contributed through an open pull request and reviewed for quality, novelty and clarity. Every task defines its inputs, expected outputs and a preferred metric, so results can be aggregated across very different problem types.

Tasks come in two formats. JSON tasks list examples with targets or multiple-choice options and are scored automatically. Programmatic tasks are Python code that interacts with the model through generation and scoring calls, which allows multi-turn interaction and custom scoring logic.

The following table summarizes the main components of the benchmark.

ComponentWhat it containsPurpose
JSON tasksFixed examples with targetsSimple, reproducible scoring
Programmatic tasksPython task definitionsInteractive or custom evaluation
KeywordsLabels such as logical reasoningGrouping tasks by ability
Human baselinesScores from expert ratersReference point for model results
Canary stringUnique identifier in task filesDetecting training data contamination
Main components of BIG-bench

Task categories and scoring metrics

BIG-bench tasks are tagged with keywords that describe the tested ability, and many tasks carry several tags. Coverage is deliberately uneven: contributors were encouraged to submit tasks they believed language models would find difficult, so the collection leans toward unusual or adversarial problems.

CategoryExample task typeSkill probed
Logical reasoningDeduction from stated premisesMulti-step inference
MathematicsMulti-digit arithmeticExact symbolic computation
LinguisticsRules of an invented languageGeneralization from few examples
Common senseEveryday physical situationsWorld knowledge
Social reasoningAmbiguous questions about groupsBias and fairness behavior
CodePredicting program outputFormal reasoning
Representative task categories

Each task reports a preferred metric, most often multiple-choice grade, exact string match or text-overlap metrics such as BLEU and ROUGE. To compare tasks with different metrics, results are normalized to a 0-100 scale, where 0 corresponds to a weak baseline such as random guessing and 100 to the best achievable score.

BIG-bench Lite and BIG-bench Hard

Running all of BIG-bench is expensive, so two widely used subsets emerged. BIG-bench Lite is an official selection of 24 JSON tasks chosen for diversity and low evaluation cost. BIG-bench Hard, often abbreviated BBH, is a later selection of 23 challenging tasks on which earlier models scored below the average human rater.

BBH became particularly influential because it showed that chain-of-thought prompting lifts performance on many of these tasks substantially, in several cases above the average human rater. Many current model reports cite BBH rather than the full benchmark.

VersionNumber of tasksMain use
Full BIG-bench200+Broad research on scaling behavior
BIG-bench Lite24Cheap, diverse summary score
BIG-bench Hard23Reasoning tests, often with chain of thought
Full benchmark compared with its main subsets

What BIG-bench revealed about scaling

The original study evaluated model families of many sizes and found that aggregate performance improves smoothly with scale, yet remains well below expert human raters on most tasks. Some tasks, however, showed sharp jumps in performance at a certain model size, a pattern often described as emergent or breakthrough behavior.

Later analysis argued that many of these jumps depend on the choice of metric: exact match turns gradual improvement into an apparent sudden leap, while continuous metrics show steadier progress. The study also reported that social bias tends to increase with scale in ambiguous contexts and that larger models are better calibrated on multiple-choice tasks.

Another finding concerned model families. Models from different developers with similar parameter counts reached broadly similar aggregate scores, which suggested that scale and training data volume mattered more than architectural details for this kind of broad survey. Sparse mixture-of-experts models gained less per total parameter than dense models, a reminder that parameter count alone is an imperfect scale measure.

How BIG-bench compares with other benchmarks

BIG-bench differs from neighboring benchmarks mainly in breadth and origin. Most benchmarks target one skill and are built by a single team, whereas BIG-bench crowdsources hundreds of heterogeneous tasks.

BenchmarkScopeTypical format
BIG-bench200+ diverse tasksMixed multiple choice and generation
MMLU57 academic subjectsMultiple choice
GSM8KGrade-school math word problemsFree-form numeric answer
HumanEvalPython programmingCode checked by unit tests
HellaSwagCommonsense sentence completionMultiple choice
BIG-bench alongside related benchmarks

Limitations and pitfalls in using BIG-bench

BIG-bench is valuable for research but has known weaknesses that affect how results should be read.

  • Uneven task quality: crowdsourced tasks vary in size, and some contain only a few dozen examples, which makes their scores noisy.
  • Benchmark contamination: task files are public, so they can leak into pretraining data despite the canary string.
  • Benchmark saturation: frontier models now score near the ceiling on many tasks, especially within BBH.
  • Prompt sensitivity: few-shot format and chain of thought can change scores by large margins.
  • Aggregate scores hide detail: a single average can mask strong gains on some tasks and failures on others.

Responsible use therefore means reporting the subset, prompt format and number of shots, and checking per-task results instead of relying on one headline number.

A plain-language summary

BIG-bench is like a huge exam with hundreds of different question papers, written by many different teachers. Some papers test math, some test logic, some test jokes or invented languages, and many were written specifically to be hard for computers.

Researchers give this exam to AI language models of different sizes to see what bigger models learn to do and where they still fail. Because the questions are public, a model may have seen some of them before, so scores need careful reading.

An example from practice

A research team at a university lab trains three language models with 1, 7 and 30 billion parameters and wants to know whether the extra compute improves reasoning. Instead of running the full benchmark, the team evaluates all three on BIG-bench Hard with 3-shot prompts, once with direct answers and once with chain-of-thought prompting.

The direct-answer scores rise only modestly with size, while the chain-of-thought scores of the largest model rise by more than 15 points on tasks such as logical deduction and date understanding. Before publishing, the team searches its pretraining corpus for the BIG-bench canary string, finds a small number of matches and removes the affected tasks. The final report lists per-task results, prompt formats and the contamination check, so other groups can reproduce and interpret the numbers.