Backlash · robotics

Also known as: gear backlash

On this page 7

Backlash in robotics is the lost motion in a drivetrain: the small angular or linear clearance between mating parts, such as gear teeth, that allows the output to move a little without any movement of the input. Also called gear backlash, it is one of the most important error sources in robot actuators, because every joint that uses a gearbox, belt or lead screw inherits some of it.

Backlash matters most when a joint reverses direction or when external load changes sign. During that reversal the motor turns through the gap before the teeth make contact again, so the joint position briefly stops following the command. In precision arms, legged robots and haptic devices, this hidden dead zone degrades positioning accuracy, stiffness and control stability.

How backlash arises in a drivetrain

Backlash appears because mating parts need deliberate clearance to run. Gear teeth require room for lubricant film, thermal expansion and manufacturing tolerance; without it, the mesh would bind, heat up and wear rapidly. The clearance is measured along the pitch circle as circumferential backlash or, at the output, as an angular backlash in arcminutes.

Each stage of a transmission contributes its own gap, and the gaps add up. Because backlash measured at the output shaft is not reduced by the gear ratio, a multistage gearbox accumulates lost motion from every mesh, plus clearances in bearings, keyways, couplings and splines. Wear later enlarges these gaps over the service life of the joint.

The following table lists the usual mechanical sources of lost motion in a robot joint and what drives their size.

SourceMechanismWhat increases it
Gear mesh clearanceGap between tooth flanksLoose center distance, thin teeth, wear
Shaft-hub connectionPlay in keys, splines or set screwsShock loads, fretting
Bearing playRadial and axial clearanceMissing preload, worn races
Belt and pulleyTooth-to-groove clearance and stretchLow tension, worn belt
Lead screw nutAxial clearance between thread flanksPlain nut without preload
Typical sources of lost motion in a robot joint

Backlash values across gearbox types

Gearbox selection largely determines how much backlash a joint will have. Manufacturers quote it in arcminutes (arcmin), where one degree equals 60 arcmin. Values below 1 arcmin count as near-zero backlash, while general-purpose spur gearboxes often exceed 30 arcmin.

The table below gives typical catalog ranges; actual values depend on the quality class, size and preload of each specific unit.

TransmissionTypical backlashCommon use in robots
Harmonic driveNear zero, below 1 arcminCollaborative and industrial arm joints
Cycloidal driveAbout 0.5 to 1 arcminHeavy industrial arm axes
Precision planetary gearboxAbout 1 to 5 arcminWrist axes, mobile manipulators
Economy planetary gearboxAbout 10 to 30 arcminHobby and low-cost robots
Spur gear trainAbout 20 to 60 arcmin or moreToy servos, simple mechanisms
Quasi-direct drive actuatorSmall, low ratio of 6:1 to 10:1Legged robots, haptic devices
Typical output backlash by transmission type

A harmonic drive achieves its low value because the flexspline engages many teeth at once under elastic preload. A planetary gearbox shares load across several planets but still needs clearance in each mesh. A quasi-direct drive actuator keeps backlash small mainly by using few gear stages and a low ratio, which also improves backdrivability.

Effects of backlash on robot control

Backlash turns a linear drivetrain into a nonlinear dead-zone element. When the motor reverses, the output stays still until the gap closes, and then the teeth meet with an impact. For a controller, this produces delay, loss of stiffness and sudden torque transients precisely when precise motion is needed.

The consequences scale with arm length. A backlash of 5 arcmin at a shoulder joint with a 1 m reach yields about 1.5 mm of uncertainty at the tool, which is unacceptable for assembly but harmless for coarse material handling. The table below summarizes typical symptoms.

SymptomUnderlying causeWhere it is noticed
Limit cyclingPosition loop hunts inside the dead zoneHolding a fixed pose
Contour error at reversalsOutput lags while gap closesCircular or zigzag paths
Tooth impact noiseFlanks collide after free travelFast direction changes
Reduced joint stiffnessLoad moves output within clearanceMachining, contact tasks
Poor repeatabilityFinal position depends on approach directionPick-and-place calibration
Symptoms of backlash and their cause

A key distinction is motor-side versus load-side sensing. If the only encoder sits on the motor, the controller cannot see the backlash at all and reports a position the output never reached. A second, output-side encoder closes the loop around the gap, but it can also make the loop less stable, because the mechanical path inside the loop now contains the nonlinearity.

Methods to reduce or compensate backlash

Designers fight backlash with mechanical elimination, preload and software compensation, usually in combination. The right mix depends on accuracy targets, cost and how much friction the joint can tolerate.

  • Zero-backlash transmissions such as harmonic and cycloidal drives remove the problem at the source, at higher cost and with some compliance.
  • Split or spring-loaded gears keep two gear halves pressed against both flanks, eliminating clearance at low to moderate loads.
  • Preloaded ball screws and bearings remove axial play in linear actuators.
  • Dual-motor antibacklash drives apply opposing torque from two motors so that one always holds contact.
  • Backlash compensation in software adds a stored offset to the command whenever motion reverses.

Every remedy carries a cost, as the decision table below shows. Preload increases friction and heat, and fixed software offsets drift as gears wear.

SituationRecommended approachMain trade-off
Precision arm jointHarmonic or cycloidal reducerCost and torsional compliance
Linear axis with lead screwPreloaded ball screw nutHigher friction, lower efficiency
Large rotary axisDual-motor torque biasExtra motor and control effort
Low-cost robotSoftware reversal offsetAccuracy fades with wear
Legged or haptic robotLow-ratio quasi-direct driveLarger, heavier motor
Choosing a backlash countermeasure

Measuring backlash and common mistakes

Backlash is measured by locking the input and rocking the output with a small, defined torque, typically about 2 percent of rated torque, while a dial indicator or output encoder records the travel. Catalog values usually refer to this method, so comparing figures from different vendors requires checking the test torque and the definition used.

A frequent mistake is to confuse backlash with torsional stiffness. A harmonic drive has almost no backlash but measurable elastic windup under load, whereas a stiff spur train may have large clearance. Another error is calibrating a robot from one approach direction only, which hides the gap until the robot reverses in production. Engineers should also re-measure periodically, because backlash grows with wear and lubrication loss.

A non-technical view

Imagine turning a loose steering wheel. For the first few degrees, nothing happens to the car, and only then do the wheels respond. Backlash is that small free play inside a robot’s gears. When a motor changes direction, it first spins through the gap before the joint actually moves.

For a robot that only stacks boxes, this hardly matters. For a robot that threads screws or holds a surgical tool, a tiny gap becomes a visible error at the fingertip. That is why precise robots use special gearboxes or clever software to keep this free play as close to zero as possible.

A concrete example

A small electronics manufacturer builds a desktop SCARA robot to insert connectors into circuit boards. The first prototype uses an economy planetary gearbox with about 15 arcmin of backlash on the first joint and a motor-mounted encoder only. During testing, connectors land correctly when the arm approaches from the left but miss by about 0.6 mm when approaching from the right.

The engineers measure the gap with a dial indicator, add a reversal offset in the controller as a short-term fix, and then switch the first joint to a harmonic drive with under 1 arcmin. After the change, the insertion error drops to about 0.05 mm from either direction, the software offset is no longer needed, and first-pass assembly yield rises noticeably.