Digital Fairness Act · proposal

On this page 7

The Digital Fairness Act is a legislative proposal planned by the European Commission to modernize EU consumer & accessibility law for digital markets, targeting dark patterns, addictive design, subscription traps, unfair personalization and problematic influencer marketing. It responds to the Commission’s Fitness Check of EU consumer law on digital fairness, published in October 2024, which concluded that existing rules leave significant gaps in online consumer protection.

Because the initiative is still a proposal rather than adopted law, its final scope, legal form and deadlines remain open. Within the wider field of Tech regulation, it is expected to amend and complement existing directives rather than replace them, and to fill gaps left by platform-focused laws such as the Digital Services Act.

Why the Digital Fairness Act proposal exists

The proposal exists because the core EU consumer directives were written before app stores, in-game currencies and algorithmic pricing became mainstream. The Fitness Check examined the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, the Consumer Rights Directive and the Unfair Contract Terms Directive, and found them broadly sound in principle but difficult to enforce against digital design practices.

The Commission estimated that problematic online practices cost EU consumers several billion euros each year, and it reported widespread experience of manipulative interfaces. The evaluation also noted legal uncertainty for traders, because national authorities interpret general principles such as professional diligence differently when applied to interface design.

The table below traces the main steps of the initiative so far and the expected next stages.

StageTimingSignificance
Fitness Check publishedOctober 2024Identified gaps in digital consumer protection
Included in Commission work program2025Confirmed a legislative initiative
Call for evidence and public consultationJuly to October 2025Collected input from consumers and industry
Commission legislative proposalPlanned for 2026First formal legal text
Parliament and Council negotiationsAfter the proposalOrdinary legislative procedure; content may change
Stages of the Digital Fairness Act initiative

Practices the proposal targets

The proposal targets design and commercial practices that exploit behavioral biases rather than practices that are openly deceptive. Several of these practices are partly covered by current law, but the coverage is fragmented across instruments and depends on case-by-case assessment.

Problem areaTypical practicePossible direction of new rules
Dark patternsConfirmshaming, hidden costs, preselected optionsExplicit bans or presumptions of unfairness
Subscription trapsEasy sign-up, hard cancellation, silent renewalsSimple cancellation and renewal reminders
Addictive designInfinite scroll, streaks, autoplayDuties to assess and limit engagement features
Unfair personalizationExploiting vulnerabilities in targeted offersLimits on personalization that harms consumers
Influencer marketingUndisclosed paid promotionClear disclosure and shared responsibility
Virtual currenciesIn-game currencies that obscure real pricesPrice transparency in real money
Problem areas and the direction of possible rules

Several options discussed during the consultation would shift the burden of proof toward traders in specific situations, for example requiring a business to show that a design choice does not distort consumer decisions. Industry groups have argued that such a shift would be disproportionate for smaller firms, so this element remains one of the most contested.

How it relates to existing EU instruments

The Digital Fairness Act is designed to sit alongside existing rules, not to duplicate them. Its main contribution is expected to be horizontal consumer protection that applies to every trader, including those outside the scope of platform regulation.

InstrumentCurrent scopeGap the proposal may address
Unfair Commercial Practices DirectiveGeneral ban on misleading and aggressive practicesFew explicit rules on interface design
Consumer Rights DirectiveInformation duties and the right of withdrawalWeak rules on canceling digital subscriptions
Digital Services ActDark pattern ban for online platforms onlyOrdinary websites and apps not covered
Digital Markets ActObligations for designated gatekeepersApplies to very few companies
Omnibus DirectiveRules on reviews, rankings and price personalization disclosureDisclosure alone may not prevent harm
Relationship with neighboring EU laws

A frequent misconception is that the Digital Services Act already bans dark patterns everywhere. Its Article 25 applies only to providers of online platforms, and it expressly defers to consumer law where that law applies. The Digital Fairness Act proposal is meant to close this coverage gap for ordinary online shops and apps.

What companies should prepare for

Companies cannot comply with a text that does not yet exist, but they can reduce future adjustment costs by aligning products with principles that existing law already enforces. National consumer authorities and the Consumer Protection Cooperation network already pursue many of the targeted practices under current rules.

AreaPreparation stepBenefit under current law
SubscriptionsMake cancellation as easy as sign-upLower risk of aggressive practice findings
Interface designAudit flows for preselection and false urgencySupports professional diligence obligations
PricingShow total price in real currency earlyMeets existing price indication duties
Marketing partnersRequire disclosure of paid promotionAvoids hidden advertising claims
MinorsAssess features used heavily by young usersAnticipates stricter treatment of vulnerability
Practical preparation steps
  • Document design decisions and the testing behind them, since evidence duties may increase.
  • Track the legislative file at each stage, because the scope can change during negotiations.
  • Avoid relying on a transition period that has not been agreed; application dates will be set only in the final act.

Open questions and limitations

The most important limitation is legal uncertainty about the final text. The Commission may choose a regulation, a directive or a combination of amendments, and the choice determines whether rules apply directly or through national transposition. Observers also debate whether principle-based rules or detailed blacklists better withstand fast changes in interface design.

There is also a political tension between stronger consumer protection and the EU’s broader simplification agenda aimed at reducing administrative burden. Commentary that presents specific obligations as settled should therefore be treated with caution until Parliament and Council agree on a final act.

Explained without jargon

Many apps and websites are built to nudge people into spending more or staying longer than they intended. Examples include a cancel button hidden five menus deep, a countdown timer that is not real, or a game that sells coins instead of showing prices in euros.

The Digital Fairness Act is a planned EU law meant to stop these tricks. It is still a draft idea, so the exact rules are not fixed yet. The basic goal is simple: online shopping should be as fair as shopping in a store.

A typical use case

A European streaming service with about two million subscribers reviews its product roadmap after the Commission announces the Digital Fairness Act initiative. Its legal and design teams find that signing up takes two clicks, while canceling requires six screens, a retention offer and a final confirmation email.

Instead of waiting for the final text, the company introduces a two-step online cancellation flow, sends a reminder seven days before each annual renewal, and removes a default box that added a paid add-on. It records each change with user testing data. The result is a lower complaint rate with the national consumer authority and a product that will need only minor adjustments once the final rules are adopted.